Meet Me In The Library

(Book Reviews and Bookish Adventures…)

Review: Gillespie & I by Jane Harris


Gillespie and I by Jane Harris

Category: Fiction/Historical/Mystery – Paperback: 624 pages – Publisher: Faber and Faber (independent publisher) – Source: Chain Bookshop (Waterstones)
First Published: 2011

Longlisted for the Orange Prize 2012

Harriet Baxter, the narrator of this 624 page chunkster of a novel, is a remarkable character. So remarkable in fact that I read this solidly in just two days as I wanted to see how much of the story she spun for me in the opening chapters was in fact ‘real’.

‘It would appear that I am to be the first to write a book on Gillespie. Who, if not me, was dealt that hand?’
(opening line of the book)

In 1933 in London, the elderly Harriet is writing down the story of what happened to the artist Ned Gillespie and his family over forty years previously in Glasgow. She’s still got her dry, intelligent wit but she’s behaving slightly strangely and her days are consumed with this task of documenting the events of 1888-1889. At the very start of her story she tells the reader about Ned being her ‘soul mate’, about him eventually burning almost all his paintings and about his suicide.

It’s quite an attention-grabbing opening! What follows is an absorbing story which flicks back and forth from Harriet’s problems in 1933 to the larger tragedies of 1888-1889.

In 1888 Harriet is in her thirties, single and unusually confident. She’s not rich but she has been bequeathed enough funds to be independent for life. After a family bereavement she decides, apparently on a whim, to go and see the International Exhibition at Glasgow. When an accident on a street brings her into contact with the Gillespie family she quickly becomes a regular visitor at the family home.

At the heart of the family is Ned, a poor artist who shows some promise but is failing to hit the balance of original and commercial he needs to find to make his success. His wife, Annie, has her hands full with two daughters, the sweet tempered and almost silent Rose and the angry, tantrum-throwing Sibyl. Ned’s mother, brother and sister all live nearby and are regular visitors at the Gillespie home and Harriet comes to watch and know them all.

Hints of scandal, a trial and the eventual ruin of Ned are made from the beginning but the tragedy takes time to unfold and it is in the middle of the book that the family are suddenly thrown into a nightmarish situation that Harriet may or may not know more about than she is telling them and the reader.

And that’s as much as I am going to reveal. This is a book I would define as a mystery or psychological thriller first and a historical novel second so you need to steer clear of spoilers to enjoy it for yourself.

I found Harriet such an intriguing narrator I was sucked in from the first page and barely blinked for the rest of the reading. Harris has given her creation a sharp, sly wit:

‘She told me that her parents were dead. I did manage to get a little more out of her. To my mind, it all sounds like a fairy tale. She claims to have grown up in a tiny cottage beside a well; her father was a shoemaker, and her mother, a washerwoman. Tempted to ask: ‘And your grandparents – were they elves?’ I managed to restrain myself, just in time.’
(page 157)

Irritated with a friend of Ned’s, she reveals to the reader that she reduced him in her head to:

‘Peden the Pedant, painter of pets; postulates, prances and pirouettes’
(page 125)

In between the barbed witticisms Harriet drops hints, assesses (and assassinates) the character of everyone around her and reveals only what she wants to. Following her narrative was a fascinating journey with someone I didn’t ever want to turn my back on. Since I love whodunits this mixture of clues and catty remarks was highly entertaining despite the increasingly dark tone of the story and, although the book is rather hard to juggle as a night-time read given the number of pages and size of the book, I just didn’t want to put it down.

I can see exactly why Gillespie and I was longlisted for the Orange Prize but am stunned that it wasn’t carried forward to the shortlist. Perhaps it’s the stately pace or the intricately wrought plot that put some of the judges off? Either way, Harriet is a character I won’t forget in a hurry and I personally much preferred this deeper, more crafted novel than the likeable but rather forgettable  (to me) The Song of Achilles.

Other Thoughts: Iris on Books, Ragdoll Books, Sam Still Reading, BookNAround, IsabelCostello

List of books read in 2012 / Index of Fiction

Author: Alex in a Library

Reader, book blogger and adventuress. My home appears to be morphing into a library... I can be found on Twitter as @AlexInALibrary.

4 thoughts on “Review: Gillespie & I by Jane Harris

  1. I loved this book too! I will admit to being hoodwinked by Harriet in the initial part of the book but as soon as I figured out she wasn’t reliable I read the rest of the book as quickly as possible to find out exactly what was true. I read it before the shortlist announcement and was so sure it was going to be selected….

    Unlike you I did enjoy Song of Achilles though, so I can’t complain too much.

  2. Great review. I picked this up at a night with Jane Harris at Waterstones ages ago and still haven’t picked it up though I look at it every week and tell myself it’ll be the next book I read :) You were as stunned as plenty of people that this didn’t make the shortlist….

    • Hahaha, I know. The size meant this was one of the last books on my summer reading list I got round to reading but I was astonished at how quickly I whizzed through it. Now I have to read The Observations again. :)


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,674 other followers